Clarity and
Vagueness of the Stylistic Category
|
"Oh Dear Friend, I wish Romanticism had never been
invented in the first place," sighed Fortunat, the hero of
an 1834 novel by the Romantic author Joseph von Eichen-dorff.
That sigh has since been repeated many times over by modern
historians of the era, in grappling with a term that so
persistently eludes precise definition and yet, despite its
irritating vagueness, has long since become indispensable.
In contemporary usage, the adjective "romantic" carries an
enormous range of connotations, being applied to the scenic
roads of Europe and the hotels that dot them, to "romantic
love" in the movies and television soap operas, to sunsets
behind palm trees and cozy garden nooks, apart from standing
for certain aspects of literature, music and visual art.
When we say something is romantic, we think of sentiment and
sentimentality, a poetic, nostalgic, or dreamy mood, but one
that might also verge on the irrational, even the insane.
The term invariably has an undertone of the imaginative and
fantastic, and of a remoteness from reality paired with
longing. As antonyms, we think of mundane, banal, pedantic.
Not even the scholarly disciplines concerned with
Romanticism have been able to do more than arrive at an
approximate definition, because the content and substance of
the movement, by their very nature, invite controversial
interpretations and speculations. The only point on which
everyone seems to agree is that Romanticism was an
intellectual and artistic transition that occurred at the
turn of the eighteenth to the nineteenth century. Yet
problems arise as soon as we try to date its beginning and
end. While in the field of music, most composers from
Beethoven to Richard Strauss are considered Romantics,
literary history concentrates on two or three decades around
the year 1800. Art history either restricts itself to the
period between about 1790 and 1840, or, on the other hand,
extends the research field enormously, seeing the Romantic
attitude at work in painting from the eighteenth to the
twentieth century, which inevitably leads to an overlapping
with other stylistic categories.
Then again, due to the tendency of Romantic art to the
fantastic and irrational, it is often treated as a substream
of Symbolism, which, after many fits and starts, blossomed
in the Sturm und Drang of the late eighteenth century and
bore its finest fruit in the latter half of the nineteenth.
On the other hand, the sentimental and, as it were, cozy
aspects of Romanticism make it difficult to distinguish from
the style known in German as Biedermeier, which is usually
dated from about 1815 to 1850. And finally, since Romantic
art includes not only an escape from reality but a fearless
confrontation with it, such terms as "romantic naturalism"
and "idealistic naturalism" have been coined in an attempt
to bridge the gap. Basically all of these names reflect
scholars' embarrassment in face of a range of artistic
expressions which, unlike earlier styles such as Renaissance
and Baroque, resist being pressed into a hard and fast
system.
The word "romance" itself goes back to the Old French word
"romanz", which characterized the vernacular Romance
dialects as opposed to church Latin. Soon, verse and prose
narratives about chivalrous knights and their adventures
came to be called "romances," which developed into the
medieval "roman," a term still used in many European
languages today to designate the novel.
In the seventeenth century, we find the word employed in
two different senses. When the Englishman Thomas Baily used
the adjective "romantick" for the first time in 1650, it was
to criticize the untruth of fictional writings. At the same
period, "romantic" was applied in a positive sense to the
landscape paintings of
Claude Lorrain (1600-1682),
Nicolas Poussin (1594-1665), and
Salvator Rosa (1615-1673). So in
parallel to the motley untamed inventiveness of the
fictional world we have the "picturesqueness" of depictions
of nature informed with emotion.
In the eighteenth century, when tales of horror set in the
Gothic past came into fashion, the aspect of the eerie and
spine-tingling phantasmagoria came into play. In France, the
Shakespeare translators Letourneur and Girardin used the
term "romantique" in 1776 to characterize the emotional
qualities of a scene. And in 1777, in his Musings of a
Lonely Vagabond, the philosopher Jean Jacques Rousseau
(1712— 1778) firmly established the Romantic ideal in French
thought.
For a long period the concept remained synonymous with the
content of popular novels, with medieval chivalry and
adventures in remote times and lands. Novalis (Friedrich von
Hardenberg, 1772—1801), who was the first to speak of "the
Romantic", meant nothing other than a writer of novels.
Novalis belonged to a young generation of German authors
who, around 1800, gave the term an entirely new twist, and
who himself provided what may be the best-known definition
of Romanticism: "By giving the commonplace a high meaning,
the ordinary a mysterious aspect, the known the dignity of
the unknown, the finite an aura of infinity, I romanticize
it."
|
|
 Sir Joshua Reynolds
General Sir Banastre Tarleton
|
Jean Paul (1763-1825), explaining why everything
that fed only on longing and memory, everything
remote, dead, unknown, had the charm of
transfiguration, said that these things triggered
the magic power of the imagination and helped it
soar into infinity. And it was Novalis, again, who
formulated a rule that was taken to heart by many
painters and well as writers: "Everything seen from
a distance becomes poetry: distant mountains,
distant people, distant events. Everything becomes
romantic."
In reaction, the English painter
Joshua Reynolds
(1723— 1792), in an academy lecture of 1778,
attacked pictures that expressed nothing but vague
ideas and ignored ail rules of science and
scholarship as established by the classical art of
antiquity. This was a slap at precursor forms of
Romanticism and an argument in favor of classical
clarity, which, according to academic doctrine, was
even capable of morally improving mankind. Ever
since Reynolds, Romanticism has borne the onus of
representing anti-classicism per se. Even its
subjects, derived from the medieval world and
European Christianity, were said to run counter to
the repertoire of Greco-Roman art.
|
|
In 1820, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1749—1832) reported
on "classicists and romanticists in Italy, violently
battling one another." One could not simply jettison the
classical education if one wished to be modern, Goethe
concluded, yet neither could one belie the thought that
stemmed from the Bible. For the great mass of people, he
said, it was enough to attach the label "romantic" to
"everything that is dark, absurd, confused,
incomprehensible." Nor was all "patriotic and home-grown"
art necessarily romantic, either.
It was Goethe, celebrated by the Germans as their
quintessential classical writer, but elsewhere usually
considered a Romantic, who supplied the prime example of
that often-sought blend of classical theme with medievalist
setting, of clarity with phantasmagoria. This was his Faust,
the first French translation of which, published in 1827,
not coinci-dentally fueled the fire of French Romanticism.
Eugene Delacroix (1798-1863) illustrations to this edition
struck Goethe as being "devilishly good stuff."
The earliest, most cogent and comprehensive theories of
Romantic art were developed in the German-speaking countries
around the year 1800. This circumstance has led many
commentators to state that the Germans invented the style,
whose intellectual and aesthetic attitudes were supposedly
particularly attuned to the "German character." One such
author was the historian Gordon Craig. In his highly praised
1982 book, The Germans, Craig saw a certain melancholy
wistfulness, an undefined longing, an alienation from
reality, sentimentality, a tendency to introversion, an
unpolitical attitude, an immersion of the self in "the
mysterious forces of nature and God," and finally, a
pervasive pessimism and obsession with death as symptoms
that led to this potentially pathological alliance. Though
much of this argument is correct, many aspects of it are
placed in historically incorrect contexts.
There can be no doubt that Romanticism, though it had an
enormous resonance in Germany, was a phenomenon that
pervaded all of Europe during the late years of the
eighteenth century and the transition period to an
industrialized society in the nineteenth. It even
occasionally overleapt the borders of Europe, for instance
stimulating American painters of the late nineteenth century
to develop a unique version of the style, above all in the
field of landscape painting. As far as the unreal and eerie,
the dark and evil ingredients of the Romantic mood are
concerned, sufficient examples are found in English and
French literature and art, where they were indeed often
carried to extremes, giving rise to the concept of "black
Romanticism."
|

Giovanni Battista Piranesi
Carceri
1761
|
An indicative example is the
interpretation placed on the work of the Italian
engraver Giovanni Battista Piranesi
(1720—1778). Piranesi was an extravagant artist. His
penchant for the fantastic culminated in the dungeon imagery
of the Carceri, depicting interiors that ran counter to all
spatial logic, fitted with instruments of torture that
called orgies of violence to mind. The demoniacal character
of these prints inspired the English writer Thomas De Quincey (1785 —1859) to his Confessions of an English
Opium-Eater, which, on its publication in 1822, caused a
furore throughout Europe and had a profound influence on on
French Romanticism in particular. Alfred de Musset
(1810-1857) translated the book in 1828, and stimulated
later terror fantasies, including an "aesthetics of evil,"
among such writers as Charles Nodier (1780-1844), Victor
Hugo (1802-1885), Theophile Gautier (1811-1872), and
Charles
Baudelaire (1821-1867).
|
|

Giovanni Battista Piranesi
Self-Portrait
|
|
| |
Giovanni Battista Piranesi
(b Mogliano, nr Mestre, 4 Oct 1720; d Rome, 9 Nov
1778).
Italian etcher, engraver, designer, architect, archaeologist and
theorist. He is considered one of the supreme exponents of
topographical engraving, but his lifelong preoccupation with
architecture was fundamental to his art. Although few of his
architectural designs were executed, he had a seminal influence
on European Neo-classicism through personal contacts with
architects, patrons and visiting artists in Rome over the course
of nearly four decades. His prolific output of etched plates,
which combined remarkable flights of imagination with a strongly
practical understanding of ancient Roman technology, fostered a
new and lasting perception of antiquity. He was also a designer
of festival structures and stage sets, interior decoration and
furniture, as well as a restorer of antiquities. The interaction
of this rare combination of activities led him to highly
original concepts of design, which were advocated in a body of
influential theoretical writings. The ultimate legacy of his
unique vision of Roman civilization was an imaginative
interpretation and re-creation of the past, which inspired
writers and poets as much as artists and designers.
|
Impulses from the Eighteenth Century
|
The example of Piranesi in itself suggests the enormous
influence exerted by eighteenth-century art on the emergence
of Romanticism. Many of the ideas developed back then were
revived at the turn of the nineteenth century, and
incorporated into a new philosophical and artistic view of
the world.
From the late seventeenth century until well into the
following decades, for example, artists and intellectuals in
France and elsewhere struggled with the question of the
extent to which the dominant classical model should be
retained. Advocates of "modernity" doubted the continuing
validity of its norms. This reservation not only led to a
reevaluation of Judeo-Christian culture, it subsequently
raised the issue of what artistic standards could take the
place of the classical codex. Instead of an aesthetics based
on ineluctable values, there developed in England and France
a doctrine of the beautiful based on individual taste and
sensibility. The feeling and "sentiment" of the individual
artist and viewer of art now became the key factor.
Ultimately this implied a turn to a psychological approach
to art, which by the middle of the nineteenth century had
begun to concentrate on its more sensational aspects.
Divergencies from the normal and mundane led writers and
artists into the realm of the "romanesque", as the French
philosopher Charles de Montesquieu (1689-1755) put it, the
realm of the exciting, alarming, and the range of qualities
which at the time were subsumed under the notion of "the
interesting." Artistic spontaneity that ignored all
borderlines, strokes of genius and creative intoxication
which spirited the artist into exotic, archaic, and barbaric
realms, were praised as the new means of aesthetic
experimentation.
In the book A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origins of Our
Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful, published in 1757,
Edmund Burke (1729-1797) paved the road to an aesthetics of
awesome and pleasurable terrors. After Burke's attempt to
base the visual arts on a theory of human passions, the
categories of the grand and sublime, the archaically rugged,
the mental stimuli provoked by the bizarre, obscure,
chaotic, even the shock effects which exposed the depths and
abysses of the human soul, came increasingly to figure in
European thinking as the motive forces behind truly
compelling works of art.
Around the time of Burke's treatise, the concept of the
"picturesque" became a key term of the epoch. As in "romanesque"
landscapes a la
Claude Lorrain,
Nicolas Poussin, and
Salvator Rosa, the word connoted psychological moods
triggered by certain themes, but also by certain modes of
formal depiction. The year 1795 saw the publication of Uvedale Price's Essays on the Picturesque, followed around
the turn of the century by several publications by Richard
Payne Knight, who maintained that picturesqueness was based
above all on values of light and color. This amounted to a
theoretical anticipation of the dissolution of concrete
subject matter into pure coloristic effects, which a short
time later would be put into practice most superbly by
William Turner (1775-1851) in watercolors and oils of a
decidedly Romantic flavor.
As we can see, much of what moved Romantic artists around
and after 1800 had already been prepared in theory years
before. This also holds for artistic practice. A good
example is the English Garden, which emerged around 1720 and
whose apparently untamed, natural tree groupings burst the
geometric constrictions of the French Baroque garden, had
from the start been looked upon as a reservoir of
picturesque and atmospheric moods. It was no coincidence
that the diverse views and vistas of the English Garden were
often based on the romantic pictures of
Claude Lorrain.
After the appearance of Burke's treatise on the sublime,
gardens were increasingly fitted out with artificial ruins,
Gothic chapels, Chinese pagodas, and Moorish kiosks. Their
layouts were suffused with the same sublime longing for
distant places and times, a penchant for the exotic and
medieval, and an aesthetics of decline and decay, which
would come to characterize later Romantic painting.
Even more: The landscape gardener William Chambers
(1726-1786) planned (though never executed) landscapes of
"terror" and "melancholy" that would have fit seamlessly
into pre- and early Romantic Gothic novels. He envisaged
burned out and inundated ruins populated by half-starved
wild animals, instruments of torture strewn about the
grounds, subterranean dungeons from which the screams of the
martyred could be heard, artificial volcanoes spewing fiery
red clouds of smoke. In gloomy caves visitors to the park
would come across wax corpses of famous kings and the most
heinous criminals of all time, as eerie celestial music from
water organs played in the background. Not only would the
pedestrian be visually and acoustically assaulted but
physically as well, by artificial earthquakes, electric
shocks, mechanical rainshowers, and sudden explosions. A
walk through the park was to be transformed into a
theatrical spectacle, a spine-chilling experience.
The English Neo-Gothic style that arose in close
conjunction with the gardens in the eighteenth century, soon
became a means of romantic self-expression on the part of
its first contractors. Strawberry Hill, for instance, was
based on the ideas of Horace Walpole (1717—1797), an
aristocratic art collector who in addition, with The Castle
of Otranto (1764), penned one of the earliest horror novels
in literary history. The interior decoration of Walpole's
house was derived from Gothic cathedrals and funerary
chapels, an extravagant suffusion of the private sphere with
the enigmatic sacred aura of the Middle Ages.
The medieval chivalrous romance had, as it were, found its
concrete setting in preindustrial England. This was even
more strikingly the case with Fonthill Abbey (built
1796—1807). Once again its builder, William Beckford
(1759-1844), was the author of an "oriental" novel, Vathek,
of 1786. Initially conceived as a church, painting gallery
and sepulcher, the huge complex of buildings in the
Neo-Gothic style was soon converted into a residence. Those
who lived there must have felt lost in the overwhelmingly
dimensioned, cavernous rooms and staircases descending into
abysmal depths.
Another eighteenth-century phenomenon that fits into the
prehistory of Romanticism is the change in people's
experience of distant and foreign places. This change
initially took place with respect to that traditional land
of European dreams, Italy. For about two centuries
well-placed young men had been travelling to Italy to expand
their knowledge of antique sites and Renaissance art. In
addition to this educational interest, in the eighteenth
century ever more travellers felt the desire to cultivate
moods, feelings, and sensations, especially those inspired
by the beauties of the Italian landscape.
At the same time, the English in particular took
water-colorists along with them on their journey in order to
record the atmosphere they so enjoyed. Ever since Burke and
that
magic word, the sublime, their interest had been
increasingly attracted by areas seen on the way south which
were especially picturesque or thrilling.
While the Swiss Alps, the quintessence of sublime
landscape, had already been painted in the 1760s by William
Pars (1742-1782), Lord Byron (1788-1824) subsequently raised
the Rhine Valley and Venice to embodiments of romantic
scenery, and soon streams of tourists were following in his
footsteps. For young intellectuals and artists, the poet
Byron became a symbolic figure of Romantic melancholy. In
addition, with his travels in Albania and Greece, where he
fought in the war of independence against the Turks, Byron
embodied that striving for ever more distant and exotic
climes which, likewise, had its roots far back in the
eighteenth century.
|
| |
William
Pars
(b London, 28 Feb 1742; d Rome, 1782). English
painter. He first established himself in London as a portrait
painter, exhibiting at the Society of Artists in 1760 and at the
Free Society of Artists from 1761. In 1764 he won the third
premium of the Royal Society of Arts for his history painting
depicting Caractacus before the Emperor Claudius
(untraced). In the same year he was selected by the Dilettanti
Society to accompany Richard Chandler and Nicholas Revett on an
archaeological expedition to Asia Minor and Greece (1764–6). His
views of Classical monuments in Asia Minor were engraved and
published in Ionian Antiquities (1769), while those he
made in Greece, which included pioneering drawings of the
Parthenon sculptures, were used in the second volume of James
Stuart’s Antiquities of Athens (1777). In 1769 seven of
the crisp, coolly lit watercolour originals (London, BM) with
their lively figures (probably influenced by Stuart’s own
gouache drawings) were exhibited at the Royal Academy; Pars was
elected ARA the following year.
|
| |
|
|
|

William
Pars
Bridge near Mount Grimsel
1770
Watercolor
British Museum, London
|

William
Pars
The Glacier of Grindelwald
1770
Watercolor
British Museum, London
|
| |

William
Pars
The Valley of Lauterbrunnen and the Staubbach
1770
Watercolor
British Museum, London
|
| |

William
Pars
The Devil's Bridge in the Canton of Uri
1770
Watercolor
British Museum, London
|
| |

William
Pars
The Rhone Glacier and the Source of the Rhone
1770
Watercolor
British Museum, London
|
| |
|
In Germany in the 1770s, Johann Gottfried Herder (1744-1803) attempted to make
the Orient popular, an attempt continued by Friedrich Schlegel (1772—1829), who
in 1800 declared that "the supremely romantic" must be sought "in the Orient" -
which for him encompassed North Africa and all of Asia. Schlegel also waxed
enthusiastic about the travel reports of Georg Forster (1754-1794), who had accompanied
Captain Cook on a South Seas expedition in 1772— 1775. In
France, the heroes of the novels of Abbe Prevost (Manon
Lescaut, 1797) and Bernardin de Saint-Pierre (Paul et Virginie, 1788), surfeited with civilization, experienced
their adventures in the New World, as later did Francois Rene Chateaubriand's (1768-1848) "romantic" hero Rene (Rene,
1802), in French America.
Finally, mention must certainly be made of the new role
that landscape painting had begun to play. Art theory in
earlier eras had denigrated this genre, since it could not
fulfil the classical demands which were met above all by
history painting. In academic instruction this judgement was
largely to retain its validity far into the nineteenth
century. Yet already in the eighteenth, when such thinkers
as Henri Rousseau, Denis Diderot (1713-1784), and
Friedrich
Schiller (1759—1805) had lamented the alienation of man from
nature, a fundamental change in attitude had begun to
emerge. The subjectively felt moods of landscape, impossible
to capture in rules, now came to be valued as qualities in
their own right.
Burke had viewed landscape as the arena of the sublime, and
accordingly, wild, untamed nature, the Scottish highlands or
the Alpine ranges - dramatic scenery in general, as a
setting for thrilling occurrences — increasingly attracted
artists' attention. The French painter
Claude-Joseph Vernet
(1714-1789) depicted storms at sea and foundering ships;
Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg of Strasbourg (1740—1812)
took up
Vernet's themes before eventually, in England,
applying their sensational effects principally to depictions
of industrial landscapes. Portions of German and English
Romanticism after 1800, and American Romanticism during the
nineteenth century, then exalted the landscape to a
favorite, and often enough symbolically charged subject.
|
| |
Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg
(b Strasbourg, 31 Oct 1740; d London, 11 March
1812). Alsatian painter, illustrator and stage designer, active
in France and England. Loutherbourg’s father, Philipp Jakob
(1698–1768), was an engraver and miniature painter to the court
of Darmstadt. In 1755 he took his family to Paris, where
Loutherbourg became a pupil of Carle Vanloo; he also attended
Jean-Georges Wille’s engraving academy in the Quai des Augustins
and Francesco Casanova’s studio. Wille directed Loutherbourg’s
attention to 17th-century Dutch landscape artists, such as
Philips Wouwerman and Nicolaes Berchem, and in 1763 Denis
Diderot noticed the inspiration of the latter in Loutherbourg’s
first Salon exhibit, a landscape with figures (Liverpool, Walker
A.G.). In this and other works, focus is on the foreground
figures, which are framed by natural formations that
occasionally fall away to reveal distant horizons. This informal
style found favour with the French public; Loutherbourg’s vivid,
fresh colour and ability to catch specific light and weather
conditions made the pastoral subjects of François Boucher and
his school seem contrived and fey. Rather more romanticized were
Loutherbourg’s shipwreck scenes (e.g. A Shipwreck, exh.
Salon 1767; Stockholm, Nmus.), inspired by Claude-Joseph Vernet,
and pictures of banditti recalling Salvator Rosa. Loutherbourg
became the most prolific painter to exhibit at the Salon between
1762 and 1771. In 1766 he was elected to the Académie Royale de
Peinture et de Sculpture and nominated as a Peintre du Roi.
|
| |
|
| |

Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg
An Avalanche in the Alps
1803
oil on canvas
Tate Gallery, London
|
| |

Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg
Abendliche Seelandschaft mit Cumberland
|
| |

Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg
Coalbrookdale bei Nacht
|
| |

Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg
Defeat of the Spanish Armada
|
Literature and Philosophy Set the Tone
|
The Romantic Movement was able to recur
to the rich stores of material provided by the eighteenth
century in many respects. But rather than merely developing this
material, it reshaped it into an entirely new view of the world.
The first signs of this became apparent in German literature and
philosophy around the year 1800.
At the beginning stood such works as Goethe's epic,
Torquato Tasso (1790), or Wilhelm Heinse's (1746-1803)
Ardinghello (1787), Italian fantasies suffused with early
Romantic nostalgia. Wilhelm Heinrich Wackenroder's
(1773-1798) Effusions of an Art-Loving Friar (1797) and
Ludwig Tieck's (1773—1853) Franz Sternbald's Peregrinations
(1798) followed suit, but now describing Italy not as the
land of classical art but as that of churches, palaces,
museums, seat of the papacy, center of the Christian world.
Especially important for the formation of Romantic thought
was the novel Heinrich von Ofterdingen (published 1802) and
the lyric cycle Hymns to the Night (1800), both from the pen
of the young Novalis. Further, the tradition of Gothic tales
of terror found a continuation not onlv in trivial
literature but in the genius and divided reality of an E. T.
A. Hoffmann (1776—1823).
Tieck worked from 1799 to 1801 on his German translation of
Cervantes's Don Quixote, "the perfect masterpiece of higher
Romantic art," as August Wilhelm Schlegel (1767— 1845)
called it a short time later. Schlegel's interest also
concentrated on Italian literature of the fourteenth to
sixteenth centuries. But above all, from 1797 he translated
the works of Shakespeare, and firmly implanted the great
"anticlassical" English author in the German Romantic canon.
Another British contribution eagerly accepted throughout
Europe, but especially in Germany, was the Ossian, a
literary sensation of the latter half of the eighteenth
century which, though purported to be the poem of an Old
Gaelic bard, turned out to be largely a new imitation,
written by a Scotsman by the name of James Macpherson.
Ossian accorded perfectly with that Romantic enthusiasm for
the remote past which also expressed itself in the
rediscovery of the German Middle Ages, the Nibelungenlied,
and the minnesongs, or love lyrics, of the Hohenstauffen
period. After the minnesingers came the mastersingers, as
embodied by Hans Sachs of Nuremberg (1494-1576). With Tieck
and Wackenroder, an enthusiasm for the "Germanic" character
of the Durer period entered a harmonious marriage with that
for things Italian, the Renaissance, Italian poetry, and the
painting of
Michelangelo (1475-1564) and
Raphael
(1483-1520).
Seen as a whole, this literature, whether newly written or
adapted, emphasized the emotions felt and the atmosphere
sensed in face of landscapes seen or imagined, as well as
subjectively negating classical rules. Its broad-based
recurrence to the most diverse eras and cultures reflected
an urge to create universal links and bonds; yet its
parallel emphasis on Christian values was intended to have
current relevance, and its revival of the local past was
aimed at strengthening national consciousness. The latter
was particularly evident in the case of the fairy-tales
written by Romantic authors, and the collections of
folktales and songs of the period. Both fields were
veritably predestined to serve as repositories of Romantic
fantasy. They opened up a realm of the miraculous, not to
mention the horrifying and cruel. But above all the
fairy-tale anthologies, foremost that of the Brothers Grimm
(1812), hoped to discover the buried wellsprings of the
German popular soul.
|
 |
 |
 |
|
Durer
Lamentation over the Dead Christ 1500 |
Michelangelo
The Holy Family
1506 |
Raphael
St George and the Dragon
1506 |
|
|
|
In the other European countries as
well, the role of literature as a catalyst for Romanticism
cannot be emphasized strongly enough. In England, the tradition
of the Gothic novel continued unbroken from the eighteenth to
far into the nineteenth century, culminating in the works of
Jane Austen (1775-1817) and Mary Shelley (Frankenstein, 1818),
and finally in those of the American Edgar Allen Poe
(1809-1849). Also unbroken since the eighteenth century were the
influence of Ossian, of John Milton's (1608-1674)
Paradise Lost and Paradise Regained, and of Edward Young's
Night Thoughts (1742—1745). The preface written in 1798 by
William Wordsworth (1770—1850) to Coleridge's Lyrical
Ballads, in its emphasis on nature as a counterworld to
society, is considered to mark the inception of the English
Romantic Movement.
In France, in the wake of the Revolution around 1800, the
Napoleonic Era had seen the emergence of first, quite
idiosyncratic versions of Romanticism. An approach
comparable to German developments was reflected in
Chateaubriand's publication of 1802, The Spirit of
Christianity, or The Beauties of the Christian Religion, in
which the novels Atala and Rene were included. Here
Christianity was reinterpreted on an aesthetic basis. In a
typically Romantic ambivalence, faith was tempered by doubt,
hope by melancholy, enthusiasm for a universal life by fear
of what lurked in the depths of the human soul. The book on
Germany by Madame Germaine de Stael (1766-1817), published
in London in 1813 and, after Napoleon's fall, in Paris in
1814, popularized the Romantic philosophy and literature of
Germany and recommended that the French overcome moribund
neoclassicism with its aid.
In the Jena Circle mentioned above, not only writers but
philosophers, such as the Schlegel brothers, Johann Gottlieb
Fichte (1762—1814), Friedrich Wilhelm Schelling (1775 —
1854), and also the Protestant theologian Friedrich
Schleier-macher (1768-1834), contributed to the journal
Athenaum, which appeared from 1789 to 1800 and may
justifiably be called the first and clearest manifesto of
Romanticism.
Its main purpose was to supplant the scientific, empirical
view of the world by a "poetical" one. Contemporary society,
these authors believed, lacked a binding mythology whose
contents and symbols would be capable of expressing what
eluded rational thought, and which could come into being
only through idealism. Were this to be achieved, modern
history would lead to a truly divine realm on earth. This
would entail a shift of the external, confessional forms of
religion into the consciousness of the individual. Only the
creative self was capable of measuring the infinite. An
important mediatory role in this process would be played by
nature.
August Wilhelm Schlegel compared the silent dialogue
between spectator and nature to Holy Communion, and many a
Protestant theologian placed the experience of nature on the
same plane as the experience of the sacrament. Art, too,
came to be seen in an ever more religious light. All fields
of human thought and creativity were to contribute to a
revolution of existence, were to proclaim the liberty of the
individual with all of its consequences, from triumphant
omnipotence to despairing loneliness.
It was precisely this split in the human character, thought
the Romantics, that would enable man to rise above himself.
Change and transformation, a liberation from norms, and a
blurring of borderlines became the program of the movement.
Contradictions and existential crises were considered not a
negative but a positive, creative factor, encouraging what
Schlegel called "the progressive," an incessant process of
becoming. Despite the positive tenor of the program,
however, its high claims contained the seed of despair, of
an absolute weariness with life. Jean Paul gave this the
name "Weltschmerz", but even before him, Chateaubriand and
Byron had raised comparable feelings and literary characters
to icons of the modern, Romantic myth.
The Romantic Movement saw itself as embodying the new
mythology of modern Europe, as a kind of summing up and
"progressive" continuation of European thought and
achievement since the Christian Middle Ages, aimed at
emancipating the human individual from his role of subject
and giving him a meaningful place in a contemporary age
whose political and industrial revolutions had lent all the
more urgency to the question of meaning.
Seen in this light, Romanticism, for all its suffering at
the state of the world, was at least initially and in its
best works something quite different from a pathetic
self-abnegation. Rather, it was borne by the optimism of new
beginnings, by an idealism that envisioned the whole of
religion, philosophy, politics, art, psychology, and
individual destinies raised to a new, meaningful, and
forward-looking plane. This universal goal explains why the
Romantics made continual borrowings from earlier epochs and
yet reached quite different intellectual conclusions and
artistic results. It was only when their ideals foundered on
the rocks of political and economic reality that many
proponents of Romanticism retreated into a domestic and
non-committal "inwardness."
|
see collections:
Joseph Mallord William Turner
Claude-Joseph Vernet
|
|
|
|
|

|