|
Henry David Thoreau

|
|
|
Henry David Thoreau
American writer
born July 12, 1817, Concord, Massachusetts, U.S.
died May 6, 1862, Concord
Main
American essayist, poet, and practical philosopher, renowned for having
lived the doctrines of Transcendentalism as recorded in his masterwork,
Walden (1854), and for having been a vigorous advocate of civil
liberties, as evidenced in the essay “Civil Disobedience” (1849).
Early life
Thoreau was born in 1817 in Concord, Massachusetts. Though his family
moved the following year, they returned in 1823. Even when he grew
ambivalent about the village after reaching manhood, it remained his
world, for he never grew ambivalent about its lovely setting of
woodlands, streams, and meadows. Little distinguished his family. He was
the third child of a feckless small businessman named John Thoreau and
his bustling, talkative wife, Cynthia Dunbar Thoreau. His parents sent
him in 1828 to Concord Academy, where he impressed his teachers and so
was permitted to prepare for college. Upon graduating from the academy,
he entered Harvard University in 1833. There he was a good student, but
he was indifferent to the rank system and preferred to use the school
library for his own purposes. Graduating in the middle ranks of the
class of 1837, Thoreau searched for a teaching job and secured one at
his old grammar school in Concord. But he was no disciplinarian, and he
resigned after two shaky weeks, after which he worked for his father in
the family pencil-making business. In June 1838 he started a small
school with the help of his brother John. Despite its progressive
nature, it lasted for three years, until John fell ill.
A canoe trip that he and John took along the Concord and Merrimack
rivers in 1839 confirmed in him the opinion that he ought to be not a
schoolmaster but a poet of nature. As the 1840s began, Thoreau took up
the profession of poet. He struggled to stay in it and succeeded
throughout the decade, only to falter in the 1850s.
Friendship with Emerson
Sheer chance made his entrance to writing easier, for he came under the
benign influence of the essayist and poet Ralph Waldo Emerson, who had
settled in Concord during Thoreau’s sophomore year at Harvard. By the
autumn of 1837, they were becoming friends. Emerson sensed in Thoreau a
true disciple—that is, one with so much Emersonian self-reliance that he
would still be his own man. Thoreau saw in Emerson a guide, a father,
and a friend.
With his magnetism Emerson attracted others to Concord. Out of their
heady speculations and affirmatives came New England Transcendentalism.
In retrospect it was one of the most significant literary movements of
19th-century America, with at least two authors of world stature,
Thoreau and Emerson, to its credit. Essentially it combined romanticism
with reform. It celebrated the individual rather than the masses,
emotion rather than reason, nature rather than man. Transcendentalism
conceded that there were two ways of knowing, through the senses and
through intuition, but asserted that intuition transcended tuition.
Similarly, the movement acknowledged that matter and spirit both
existed. It claimed, however, that the reality of spirit transcended the
reality of matter. Transcendentalism strove for reform yet insisted that
reform begin with the individual, not the group or organization.
Literary career
In Emerson’s company Thoreau’s hope of becoming a poet looked not only
proper but feasible. Late in 1837, at Emerson’s suggestion, he began
keeping a journal that covered thousands of pages before he scrawled the
final entry two months before his death. He soon polished some of his
old college essays and composed new and better ones as well. He wrote
some poems—a good many, in fact—for several years. Captained by Emerson,
the Transcendentalists started a magazine, The Dial; the inaugural
issue, dated July 1840, carried Thoreau’s poem “Sympathy” and his essay
on the Roman poet Aulus Persius Flaccus.
The Dial published more of Thoreau’s poems and then, in July 1842,
the first of his outdoor essays, “Natural History of Massachusetts.”
Though disguised as a book review, it showed that a nature writer of
distinction was in the making. Then followed more lyrics, and fine ones,
such as “To the Maiden in the East,” and another nature essay,
remarkably felicitous, “A Winter Walk.” The Dial ceased publication with
the April 1844 issue, having published a richer variety of Thoreau’s
writing than any other magazine ever would.
In 1840 Thoreau fell in love with and proposed marriage to an
attractive visitor to Concord named Ellen Sewall. She accepted his
proposal but then immediately broke off the engagement at the insistence
of her parents. He remained a bachelor for life. During two periods,
1841–43 and 1847–48, he stayed mostly at the Emersons’ house. In spite
of Emerson’s hospitality and friendship, however, Thoreau grew restless;
his condition was accentuated by grief over the death in January 1842 of
his brother John, who died of lockjaw after cutting his finger. Later
that year he became a tutor in the Staten Island household of Emerson’s
brother, William, while trying to cultivate the New York literary
market. Thoreau’s literary activities went indifferently, however, and
the effort to conquer New York failed. Confirmed in his distaste for
city life and disappointed by his lack of success, he returned to
Concord in late 1843.
Move to Walden Pond
Back in Concord Thoreau rejoined his family’s business, making pencils
and grinding graphite. By early 1845 he felt more restless than ever,
until he decided to take up an idea of a Harvard classmate who had once
built a waterside hut in which one could loaf or read. In the spring
Thoreau picked a spot by Walden Pond, a small glacial lake located 2
miles (3 km) south of Concord on land Emerson owned.
Early in the spring of 1845, Thoreau, then 27 years old, began to
chop down tall pines with which to build the foundations of his home on
the shores of Walden Pond. From the outset the move gave him profound
satisfaction. Once settled, he restricted his diet for the most part to
the fruit and vegetables he found growing wild and the beans he planted.
When not busy weeding his bean rows and trying to protect them from
hungry woodchucks or occupied with fishing, swimming, or rowing, he
spent long hours observing and recording the local flora and fauna,
reading, and writing A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers (1849).
He also made entries in his journals, which he later polished and
included in Walden. Much time, too, was spent in meditation.
Out of such activity and thought came Walden, a series of 18 essays
describing Thoreau’s experiment in basic living and his effort to set
his time free for leisure. Several of the essays provide his original
perspective on the meaning of work and leisure and describe his
experiment in living as simply and self-sufficiently as possible, while
in others Thoreau describes the various realities of life at Walden
Pond: his intimacy with the small animals he came in contact with; the
sounds, smells, and look of woods and water at various seasons; the
music of wind in telegraph wires—in short, the felicities of learning
how to fulfill his desire to live as simply and self-sufficiently as
possible. The physical act of living day by day at Walden Pond is what
gives the book authority, while Thoreau’s command of a clear,
straightforward but elegant style helped raise it to the level of a
literary classic.
Thoreau stayed for two years at Walden Pond (1845–47). In the summer
of 1847 Emerson invited him to stay with his wife and children again,
while Emerson himself went to Europe. Thoreau accepted, and in September
1847 he left his cabin forever.
Midway in his Walden sojourn Thoreau had spent a night in jail. On an
evening in July 1846 he encountered Sam Staples, the constable and tax
gatherer. Staples asked him amiably to pay his poll tax, which Thoreau
had omitted paying for several years. He declined, and Staples locked
him up. The next morning a still-unidentified lady, perhaps his aunt,
Maria, paid the tax. Thoreau reluctantly emerged, did an errand, and
then went huckleberrying. A single night, he decided, was enough to make
his point that he could not support a government that endorsed slavery
and waged an imperialist war against Mexico. His defense of the private,
individual conscience against the expediency of the majority found
expression in his most famous essay, “Civil Disobedience,” which was
first published in May 1849 under the title “Resistance to Civil
Government.” The essay received little attention until the 20th century,
when it found an eager audience. To many, its message still sounds
timely: there is a higher law than the civil one, and the higher law
must be followed even if a penalty ensues. So does its consequence:
“Under a government which imprisons any unjustly, the true place for a
just man is also a prison.”
Later life and works
When Thoreau left Walden, he passed the peak of his career, and his life
lost much of its illumination. Slowly his Transcendentalism drained away
as he became a surveyor in order to support himself. He collected
botanical specimens for himself and reptilian ones for Harvard, jotting
down their descriptions in his journal. He established himself in his
neighbourhood as a sound man with rod and transit, and he spent more of
his time in the family business; after his father’s death he took it
over entirely. Thoreau made excursions to the Maine woods, to Cape Cod,
and to Canada, using his experiences on the trips as raw material for
three series of magazine articles: “Ktaadn [sic] and the Maine Woods,”
in The Union Magazine (1848); “Excursion to Canada,” in Putnam’s Monthly
(1853); and “Cape Cod,” in Putnam’s (1855). These works present
Thoreau’s zest for outdoor adventure and his appreciation of the natural
environment that had for so long sustained his own spirit.
As Thoreau became less of a Transcendentalist he became more of an
activist—above all, a dedicated abolitionist. As much as anyone in
Concord, he helped to speed fleeing slaves north on the Underground
Railroad. He lectured and wrote against slavery, with “Slavery in
Massachusetts,” a lecture delivered in 1854, as his hardest indictment.
In the abolitionist John Brown he found a father figure beside whom
Emerson paled; the fiery old fanatic became his ideal. By now Thoreau
was in poor health, and when Brown’s raid on Harpers Ferry failed and he
was hanged, Thoreau suffered a psychic shock that probably hastened his
own death. He died, apparently of tuberculosis, in 1862.
Assessment
To all appearances, Thoreau lived a life of bleak failure. His
neighbours viewed him with familiarity verging on contempt. He had to
pay for the printing of A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers; when
it sold a mere 220 copies, the publishers dumped the remaining 700 on
his doorstep. Walden (the second and last of his books published during
his lifetime) fared better but still took five years to sell 2,000
copies. And yet Thoreau is now regarded as both a classic American
writer and a cultural hero of his country. The present opinion of his
greatness stems from the power of his principal ideas and the lucid,
provocative writing with which he expressed them.
Thoreau’s two famous symbolic actions, his two years in the cabin at
Walden Pond and his night in jail for civil disobedience, represent his
personal enactment of the doctrines of New England Transcendentalism as
expressed by his friend and associate Emerson, among others. In his
writings Thoreau was concerned primarily with the possibilities for
human culture provided by the American natural environment. He adapted
ideas garnered from the then-current Romantic literatures in order to
extend American libertarianism and individualism beyond the political
and religious spheres to those of social and personal life. “The life
which men praise and regard as successful is but one kind. Why,” Thoreau
asked in Walden, where his example was the answer, “should we exaggerate
any one kind at the expense of the others?” In a commercial,
conservative, expedient society that was rapidly becoming urban and
industrial, he upheld the right to self-culture, to an individual life
shaped by inner principle. He demanded for all men the freedom to follow
unique lifestyles, to make poems of their lives and living itself an
art. In a restless, expanding society dedicated to practical action, he
demonstrated the uses and values of leisure, contemplation, and a
harmonious appreciation of and coexistence with nature. Thoreau
established the tradition of nature writing later developed by the
Americans John Burroughs and John Muir, and his pioneer study of the
human uses of nature profoundly influenced such conservationists and
regional planners as Benton MacKaye and Lewis Mumford. More important,
Thoreau’s life, so fully expressed in his writing, has had a pervasive
influence because it was an example of moral heroism and an example of
the continuing search for a spiritual dimension in American life.
Major Works
The most significant and enduring works by Thoreau are listed here in
order of original publication; when he made substantial revisions,
especially in the essays, the volumes in which the revised versions
first appeared are likewise noted:
“Ktaadn and the Maine Woods” (1848; revised and expanded in The Maine
Woods, 1864); A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers (1849);
“Resistance to Civil Government” (1849; republished as “Civil
Disobedience” in A Yankee in Canada, 1866); Walden (1854); “The Last
Days of John Brown” (1860; republished in A Yankee in Canada); “Walking”
(1862; republished in Excursions, 1863); “Life Without Principle” (1863;
republished in A Yankee in Canada); and Faith in a Seed: The Dispersion
of Seeds and Other Late Natural History Writings (posthumously, 1993).
The Writings of Henry Thoreau, 20 vol. (1906, reprinted 1982), is the
standard “Walden” edition of Thoreau’s books, essays, and journal. It is
being replaced by the Princeton Edition of The Writings of Henry D.
Thoreau (starting in 1971 with the publication of its version of Walden)
which is producing books of high textual and editorial quality.
Collected Poems, ed. by Carl Bode, enlarged ed. (1964, reissued 1970),
brings together the many versions of the poetry he wrote, particularly
in his younger days.
|
|
|

|
THE ESSAYS OF THOREAU
|
Author: Henry David Thoreau (1817-1862)
First published: From 1842 to after Thoreau's death
|
|
To the nonspecialist, Thoreau's significant works could be numbered
on the fingers of both hands. Of these undoubtedly the first to come to
mind would be Walden, his most famous book, and perhaps A Week on the
Concord and Merimack Rivers. But almost as famous and perhaps even more
influential have been several of his essays, which were written on
various occasions for different purposes, and generally on rather widely
ranging subjects. More than his two famous books, his essays vary in
quality from the nearly banal to the profound, from the useless to the
useful. To the reader genuinely interested in the life and writings of
one of America's greatest and most influential writers—as well as
perhaps our most outstanding true Transcendentalist—all his works are
fascinating. But since many do concern closely related subjects and
treat these topics in a similar manner, a selection of the works can
give the heart of the essays.
Thoreau's earliest essay, possibly, is one named "The Seasons," written
when he was only eleven or twelve years old. As would be expected, it is
of importance only to the close specialist. There are also in existence
at least twenty-eight essaysvand four book reviews that Thoreau wrote
while a student at Harvard. These, too, are of greater interest to the
student interested in the young Harvardian than to the readers looking
for the Thoreau of mature ideas and style.
His first published essay was "Natural History of Massachusetts,"
printed in 1842. This work does more than promise the later man. It is,
in fact, the mature thinker and observer already arrived. Drawn chiefly
from entries in his journals, which he had begun to keep after
graduation from Harvard in 1837, it reveals his characteristics of
Transcendentalism and his keen eye for observation, an eye that was to
make him acclaimed by many people as one of America's best early
scientists. It reveals Thoreau's pleasure in viewing the world around
him and his detachment from the world of men. He believes, for example,
that one does not find health in society but in the world of nature. To
live and prosper, a person must stand with feet firmly planted in
nature. He believes, also, that society is corrupting, is inadequate for
man's spiritual needs; when considered as members of a society,
especially a political organization, men are "degraded." As a scientist,
Thoreau catalogues many aspects of natural phenomena in Massachusetts;
he notes, for example, that 280 birds live permanently in that state or
summer there or visit it passingly.
Among Thoreau's best essays is another early one, "A Winter Walk,"
published in 1843, the material of which was taken mainly from his
journal for 1841. As was generally the case with Thoreau, this essay is
lyrical and ecstatic, the lyricism being augmented by the inclusion of
various bits of Thoreau's own poetry. Thematically the essay is strung
on a long walk on a winter's day and the observations and meditations of
the author as he progresses. Both his observations and meditations are
mature, virtually as vivid and sound as those given in the later Walden.
His reactions to the physical walk are immediate and sharply detailed.
He likes to walk through the "powdery snow," and he feels that man
should live closer to nature in order to appreciate life fully. In a
Wordsworth-ian-pantheistic point of view, he feels that plants and
animals and men, if they would conform, find in nature only a "constant
nurse and friend."
Thoreau's most famous essay is "Resistance to Civil Government,"
published in 1849 and renamed, after Thoreau's death, "Civil
Disobedience," the title by which it is known today. As is often the
case, this essay grew directly from an experience by the author, this
time Thoreau's one-night imprisonment for nonpayment of his taxes, taxes
which he claimed would go to finance the Mexican War and were therefore,
in his mind, immoral. The influence of this essay has been profound,
far-reaching, and long-lasting. It served Gandhi as a guidebook in his
campaign to free India from British rule; it also served the British
Labour party in England during its early days; it offered model and hope
for the European resistance against Nazi Germany, and it has aided, more
recently, the struggle for civil rights in the South.
The essay is a bristling and defiant reaffirmation of the individualism
of man, of his moral obligation to restate his individualism and to act
on it. Government, any government, is at best an expediency. Thoreau
heartily accepts the precept "That government is best which governs
least." a thesis which logically leads to the conclusion "That
government is best which governs not at all." Government, however, still
exists, but it is not unchangeable; "A single man can bend it to his
will." Government, in Thoreau's eyes, was far from pure and beneficent.
He felt that he could not have as his government those institutions
which enslaved certain races and colors. Therefore he felt compelled to
resist his government. He felt that ten men—even one—could abolish
slavery in America if they would allow themselves to go to prison for
their belief and practice. Men of goodwill must unite. Every good man
must constitute a majority of one to resist tyranny and evil. Democracy
may not be the ultimate in systems of government, he concludes, in a
ringing statement of man's political position: "There will never be a
really free and enlightened State, until the State comes to recognize
the individual as a higher and independent power, from which all its own
power and authority are derived, and treats him accordingly."
One of Thoreau's notable essays is "A Plea for Captain John Brown,"
published in 1860, one of three on the same person, the other two being
"After the Death of John Brown," delivered at the Concord memorial
services for Brown, held the day the raider of Harper's Ferry was
hanged, and "The Last Days of John Brown," written for a memorial
service on July 4, 1860. The earliest essay of the three justifies the
actions of Brown because generally he tried to put Thoreau's convictions
into action.
"Walking," published in 1862, was taken from his journal written some
ten years earlier and used as material for lectures in the early 1850s.
It is an enthusiastic reaction to the joys of walking, "for absolute
freedom and wildness," in which Thoreau in effect boasts that the course
of progress is always westward, drawn probably from the mere fact, as
has been pointed out, that around Concord the best walking country was
to the southwest. Extremely lyrical, the essay sometimes surfaces into
sheer nonsense, as in the statement that "Above all, we cannot afford
not to live in the present. He is blessed over all other mortals who
loses no moment of the passing life in remembering the past." Such
comments caused a more deeply dedicated thinker, Herman Melville, to
react with great scorn and frequently to satirize Thoreau's easy
optimism.
"Life Without Principle," published more than a year after Thoreau's
death in 1863, was likewise drawn from the journals during the author's
most powerful decade, in the early 1850s. Delivered in 1854 as "Getting
a Living," it is a ringing statement on the dignity and real worth of
the individual, of the man. It is the voice of the self-reliant man
calling all individuals to the assertion of their self-reliance so that
they can live like men and live fully. Thoreau feels that most men
misspend their lives, especially those who are concerned merely with
getting money: "The ways by which you may get money almost without
exception lead downward. To have done anything by which you earned money
merely is to have been truly idle or worse." To be born wealthy is
disastrous— as he says in one of his pithy statements—it is rather "to
be stillborn." The wise man cannot be tempted by money. He must be free,
as Thoreau was convinced, feeling that his "connection with and
obligation to society are still very slight and transient."
The world must be composed of individuals and must live not for the
moment but for eternity. "Read not the Times. Read the Eternities."
America must reform. "Even if we grant that the American has freed
himself from a political tyrant, he is still the slave of an economical
and moral tyrant." In other ways America has not lived up to her
potential. She is not the land of the free. "What is it to be free from
King George and continue to be the slaves of King Prejudice? What is it
to be born free and not to live free?"
The everyday routines of life are necessary, to be sure, but they should
be "unconsciously performed, like the corresponding functions of the
physical body" so that the mind—the better parts of men—can rise to the
greater and noble aspects of living so that they will not discover at
death that life has been wasted.
This essay is Thoreau at his best. He is characteristically the
Transcendentalist, the individualist, voicing his opinion without
reserve, pithily and most tellingly. Thoreau was perhaps more than other
nineteenth century American writer circumscribed in his subjects for
writing. Therefore his essays are repetitious. He liked to brag that he
was widely traveled in Concord. But, though perhaps narrow in breadth,
Thoreau's writings are shafts reaching to the essence of man's being.
And a half dozen essays represent him truthfully and succinctly.
|
|
|

|
WALDEN
|
Type of work: Essays
Author: Henry David Thoreau (1817-1862)
Type of treatise: Autobiography and nature notes
Time of treatise: 1845-1847
Locale: Walden Pond, near Concord, Massachusetts
First published: 1854
|
|
More than a naturalist's record of finely observed phenomena,
Walden is a major philosophical statement on the American character, the
uses of a life of simple toil, and the values of rugged independence.
|
|
The Story
Early in the summer of 1845, Henry David Thoreau left his family home in
the village of Concord, Massachusetts, to live for two years by himself
in a rude house that he had constructed beside Walden Pond, in a far
corner of Concord township. While there he wrote in his journal about
many of the things he did and thought. He was not the owner of the land
on which he settled, but he had received the owner's permission to build
his house and to live there. His objective was really to live simply and
think and write; in addition, he proved to himself that the necessities
of food, clothing, shelter, and fuel could be rather simply obtained for
a man who desired only what he needed.
As early as March, 1845, Thoreau went out to Walden Pond and cut the
timber he needed for the framework of his house, doing all the labor
himself. When that was done and the framing in place, Thoreau bought a
shanty from an Irish railroad worker. He then tore down the shanty and
used the boards for the sidings of the house, even making use of many of
the nails already in the boards. By July, then, the house was ready for
his occupancy. Before the advent of cold weather the following fall,
Thoreau also built himself a fireplace and a chimney for cooking and
heating purposes. He also lathed and plastered the interior of the
one-room house, in order that it would be warm and comfortable during
the cold New England winter.
Having done all the work himself, and having used native materials
wherever possible, he had built the house for the absurdly low cost of
twenty-eight dollars. In addition to providing himself with a place to
live, Thoreau believed he had taught himself a great lesson in the art
of living. He was also vastly pleased that he had provided himself with
a place to live for less than a year's lodging had cost him as a student
at Harvard College.
In order to get the money needed to build the house, Thoreau had planted
about two and a half acres of beans, peas, potatoes, corn, and turnips,
which he sold at harvest time. The land on which they were grown was
lent by a neighbor who believed, along with everyone else, that the land
was good for nothing. In addition to selling enough produce to pay his
building expenses, Thoreau had enough yield left from his gardening to
provide himself with food. But he did not spend all his time working on
the house or in the garden. One of his purposes in living at Walden Pond
was to live so simply that he might have plenty of time to think, to
write, and to observe nature; and so he spent only as much time in other
labors as he had to. He had little respect for possessions and material
things. He believed, for instance, that most men were really possessed
by their belongings, and that such a literary work as the Bhagavad-Gita
was worth more than all the towers and temples of the Orient.
Thoreau was quite proud of how little money he needed to live
comfortably while at Walden Pond. The first eight months he was there he
spent only slightly more than a dollar a month for food. In addition to
some twenty-odd dollars he received for vegetables he raised, his
income, within which he lived, was slightly more than thirteen dollars.
His food consisted almost entirely of rye and Indian meal bread,
potatoes, rice, a little salt pork, molasses, and salt. His drink was
water. Seldom did he eat large portions of meat, and he never hunted.
His interest in the animals that lived in the woods and fields near
Walden Pond was the interest of a naturalist. Although he spent some
time fishing, he felt that the time he had was too valuable to spend in
catching fish to feed himself.
For the small amounts of cash he needed, Thoreau worked with his hands
at many occupations, working only so long as was necessary to provide
himself with the money his meager wants required. He kept as much time
as possible free for thinking and studying. His study consisted more of
man and nature than of books, although he kept a few well-selected
volumes about him at all times.
While at Walden Pond, summer and winter, Thoreau lived independent of
time: he refused to acknowledge days of the week or month. When he
wished to spend some time observing certain birds or animals, or even
the progress of the weather, he felt free to do so. About the only thing
to remind him that men were rushing pell-mell to keep a schedule was the
whistle of the Fitchburg Railway trains, which passed within a mile or
so of his dwelling. Not that he disliked the railroad; he thought it, in
fact, a marvel of man's ingenuity, and he was fascinated by the cargoes
which the trains carried from place to place. But he was glad that he
was not chained to the commerce those cargoes represented. As much as he
sometimes enjoyed the sound of the train, he enjoyed far more the sounds
of the birds and animals, most of which he knew, not only as a country
dweller knows them, but as the naturalist knows them as well. The loons,
the owls, the squirrels, the various kinds of fish in Walden Pond, the
migratory birds, all of these were part of his conscious existence and
environment.
People often dropped in to visit with Thoreau, who frankly confessed
that he did not consider people very important. He failed, in fact, to
tell who his most frequent visitors were. He preferred only one visitor
at a time if he were an intelligent conversationalist. Whenever he had
more visitors than could be accommodated in his small house with its
three chairs, he took them into his larger drawing room, the pine wood
which surrounded his home. Few people, it seems, came to visit him,
perhaps because he was a crusty kind of host, one who, if he had nothing
better to do, was willing to talk, but who usually had more to occupy
him than ordinary conversation.
During the winter months Thoreau continued to live comfortably at Walden
Pond, though his activities changed. He spent more time at the pond
itself, making a survey of its bottom, studying the ice conditions, and
observing the animal life which centered about the pond, which had some
open water throughout the year.
After two years of life at Walden, Thoreau left the pond. He felt no
regret for having stayed there or for leaving; his attitude was that he
had many lives to live and that he had finished with living at the pond.
He had learned many lessons there, had had time to think and study, and
had proved what he had set out to prove twenty-six months before, that
living could be extremely simple and yet fulfill the individual.
|
|
Critical Evaluation
Few contemporaries of Henry David Thoreau would have predicted the
enormous popularity his small volume, Walden, would win in our century.
Author and work were virtually neglected during Thoreau's lifetime.
Locally, he was considered the village eccentric; even his great friend
and mentor Ralph Waldo Emerson was disappointed because his young
disciple seemingly frittered away his talent instead of "engineering for
all America." After Thoreau's death in 1862, his works attracted serious
critical attention, but unfavorable reviews by James Russell Lowell and
others severely damaged his reputation. Toward the turn of the century
he began to win favorable attention again, mainly in Britain. During the
Depression of the 1930s when most people were forced to cut the frills
from their lives, Walden, whose author admonished readers voluntarily to
"Simplify, simplify, simplify!" became something of a fad. In the 1960s,
with new awareness of environment and emphasis on nonconformity, Thoreau
was exalted as a prophet and Walden as the individualists' bible.
Walden can be approached in several different ways. Obviously it is an
excellent nature book. During the Romantic era, many writers—Wordsworth,
Byron, Shelley, Emerson, Whitman, to name a few—paid tribute to nature.
But Thoreau went beyond simply rhapsodizing natural wonders. He was a
serious student of the natural world, one who would spend hours
observing a wood-chuck or tribes of battling ants, who meticulously
mapped Walden Pond, and who enjoyed a hilarious game of tag with a loon.
Like Emerson, he saw nature as a master teacher. In his observations of
nature, Thoreau was a scientist; in his descriptions, a poet; in his
interpretations, a philosopher and psychologist; and certainly he was an
ecologist in his insistence on man's place in (not over) the natural
universe, and on man's need for daily contact with the earth.
Walden may also be considered as a handbook for the simplification of
life. As such, it becomes a commentary upon the sophistication or
"refinement" of frequently distorted values and devotion to things of
civilized society. Thoreau admits the necessities of food, shelter,
clothing, and fuel, "for not till we have secured these are we prepared
to entertain the true problems of life with freedom and a prospect of
success." He then illustrates how we may strip these necessities to
essentials for survival and health, ignoring the dictates of fashion or
the yearning for luxury. "Most of the luxuries, and many of the
so-called comforts of life," he asserts, "are not only not
indispensable, but positive hindrances to the elevation of mankind."
With relentless logic he points out how making a living has come to take
precedence over living itself; how a man mortgages himself to pay for
more land and fancier clothing and food than he really requires; how he
refuses to walk to a neighboring city because it will take too long—but
then must work longer than the walk would take in order to pay for a
train ticket. He questions our dedication to "progress," noting that it
is technological, not spiritual: "We are in great haste to construct a
magnetic telegraph from Maine to Texas; but Maine and Texas, it may be,
having nothing important to communicate."
Perhaps the most serious purpose of Walden and its most powerful message
is to call men to freedom as individuals. One looks at nature in order
to learn about oneself; one simplifies one's life in order to have time
to develop that self fully; and one must honor one's uniqueness if one
is to know full self-realization. It is this emphasis on nonconformity
that has so endeared Thoreau to the young, who have adopted as their
call to life these words from the final chapter of Walden: "If a man
does not keep pace with his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a
different drummer. Let him step to the music which he hears, however
measured or far away."
There is an ease, a clarity, a concreteness to Thoreau's prose that
separates it from the more abstract, eloquent, and frequently involuted
styles of his contemporaries. The ease and seeming spontaneity are
deceptive. Thoreau revised the book meticulously during the five years
it took to find a publisher; there are five complete drafts which
demonstrate how consciously he organized not only the general outline,
but every chapter and paragraph. For an overall pattern, he condensed
the two years of his actual Walden experience into one fictional year,
beginning and concluding with spring—the time of rebirth.
Pace and tone are also carefully controlled. Thoreau's sentences and
paragraphs flow smoothly. The reader is frequently surprised to discover
that sentences occasionally run to more than half a page, paragraphs to
a page or more; syntax is so skillfully handled that one never feels
tangled in verbiage. Tone varies from matter-of-fact to poetic to
inspirational and is spiced with humor— usually some well-placed
satire—at all levels. Even the most abstract topics are handled in
concrete terms; Thoreau's ready use of images and figurative language
prepares us for twentieth century Imagist poetry.
Taken as a whole, Walden is a first-rate example of organic writing,
with organization, style, and content fused to form a work that today,
over one hundred years after its publication, is as readable and perhaps
even more timely than when it was written. In Walden, Thoreau reaches
across the years to continue to "brag as lustily as Chanticleer ... to
wake my neighbors up."
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|