Mo-tzu

Mozi, Wade-Giles romanization Mo-tzu, also spelled
Motze, Motse, or Micius, original name Mo Di (b.
470?, China—d. 391? bce, China), Chinese philosopher
whose fundamental doctrine of undifferentiated love
(jianai) challenged Confucianism for several
centuries and became the basis of a socioreligious
movement known as Mohism.
Life
Born a few years after Confucius’s death, Mozi was
raised in a period when the feudal hierarchy
instituted at the beginning of the Zhou dynasty
(12th or 11th century bce to 256 bce) was swiftly
disintegrating and China was divided into small,
constantly warring feudal states. He thus confronted
the problem that faced all thinkers in
5th-century-bce China: how to bring political and
social order out of chaos.
According to
tradition, Mozi was originally a follower of the
teachings of Confucius, until he became convinced
that Confucianism laid too much emphasis on a
burdensome code of rituals and too little on
religious teaching, at which time Mozi decided to go
his own way. Confucius, from all accounts, was
aristocratic by temperament and orientation and
dreamed of a return of the calm and peaceful days of
pomp and splendour at the beginning of the Zhou
dynasty. Mozi, on the other hand, was drawn to the
common people and looked much farther back to a life
of primitive simplicity and straightforwardness in
human relations.
Mozi’s life,
however, resembled that of Confucius in many
important respects. He was widely read and well
versed in the tradition of the Chinese Classics.
Except for a brief period when he held public
office, Mozi spent most of his life traveling from
one feudal state to another in the hope of meeting a
prince who would allow him to put his teachings into
practice. In the absence of such a prince, he had to
be content with maintaining a school and
recommending his disciples for administrative
positions. He commanded respect partly because he
lived a very simple life and was a teacher who took
his own teachings seriously. He not only condemned
offensive war but also led his followers to distant
states to prevent the outbreak of wars by
reinforcing the defending state.
The Mozi, the
principal work left by Mozi and his followers,
contains the essence of his political, ethical, and
religious teachings. The gist of it is found in the
three sets of chapters of its second section, which
give an overview of the 10 major tenets: “exaltation
of the virtuous,” “identification with the
superior,” “undifferentiated love,” “condemnation of
offensive war,” “economy of expenditures,”
“simplicity in funerals,” “will of heaven,” “on
ghosts,” “denunciation of music as a wasteful
activity,” and “antifatalism.” Since Mohism split
into three schools after Mozi’s death, the three
sets of chapters may well represent the three sets
of texts preserved by the three schools. The other
sections of the Mozi might be listed as follows: (1)
summaries and abstracts of Mozi’s teachings, (2)
discussions on logic and physical sciences, (3)
records of Mozi’s doings and sayings, and (4) a
manual of military defense.
Teachings
As a thinker, Mozi was distinctive in his insistence
on methodology. He insisted that standards of
judgment be established, and his criteria may be
summarized as the threefold test and the fourfold
standard. The threefold test reminded thinkers that
the basis, verifiability, and applicability of any
proposition must be analyzed; the fourfold standard
reminded thinkers that one should always assess the
benefits any proposition could bring to the country
and the people. Benefits were defined as enrichment
of the poor, increase of the population, removal of
danger, and regulation of disorder. To Mozi the
tests and standards were indispensable. Generalizing
further, Mozi declared that, before anything could
be said to be good, it was necessary first to
demonstrate what it was good for.
The cornerstone of
Mozi’s system was undifferentiated love. If the
world is in chaos, he said, it is owing to human
selfishness and partiality, and the prescribed
cure—in striking parallel with Christianity—is that
“partiality should be replaced by universality,”
for, “when everyone regards the states and cities of
others as he regards his own, no one will attack the
others’ state or seize the others’ cities.” The same
principle was to be applied to the welfare of the
family and of the individual. The peace of the world
and the happiness of humanity lie in the practice of
undifferentiated love. Many objections—its
impracticability, its neglect of the special claims
of one’s parents—were raised against this new
doctrine, but Mozi demonstrated that the principle
of undifferentiated love had in it both utilitarian
justification and divine sanction. He spoke of
“undifferentiated love and mutual profit” in one
breath, and he was convinced that this principle was
both the way of man and the way of heaven (tian).
Mozi’s stand on
religion makes him exceptional among Chinese
philosophers. His call to the people was for them to
return to the faith of their fathers. He might be
said to be a revivalist, a champion of religious
orthodoxy with a personal god. To Mozi, there is
heaven, heaven has a will, and this will of heaven
is to be obeyed by human beings and accepted as the
unifying standard of human thought and action: “What
is the will of heaven that is to be obeyed? It is to
love all the people in the world without
distinction.” Heaven not only “desires righteousness
and abominates unrighteousness” but also metes out
reward and punishment accordingly. The system of
Mozi, with its gospel of undifferentiated love and
the ascetic discipline as exemplified by his own
life, soon after the master’s death, was embodied in
an organized church with a succession of Elder
Masters and a considerable body of devotees. The
religion prospered for several generations before
completely disappearing.
The teachings of
Mozi, however, continued to be held in high respect
for several centuries. Down to the beginning of the
2nd century bce, writers referred to Confucianism
and Mohism in one breath as the two leading schools
of thought. But from that time, Mohism suddenly
disappeared from the intellectual scene. Critics
have generally agreed in admiring the high-minded
character of Mozi himself but considered his
teachings overdemanding and contrary to human
nature. It was not until the encounter with Western
learning in the 19th century that Mozi was
rediscovered and his teachings reappraised.
Yi Pao Mei